TheStarNeedsaCritic.org
In the wave of buyouts and layoffs hitting newspapers this season, The Kansas City Star has decided it can no longer afford a classical music critic. Paul Horsley, who took the critic’s job eight years ago, was quoted on the Web site MusicalAmerica.com as saying, “I think it was a very ‘corporate’ decision.” He added, “I think they eliminated the beat they thought they could most easily farm out.”

- PATRICIA COHEN. NY Times from Mothballing a Critic Published: June 24, 2008http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/24/arts/24arts-MOTHBALLINGA_BRF.html?_r=1&ref=arts&oref=sloginshapeimage_3_link_0
Visit our Forum and join the discussion or submit an open letter to be published on our site.http://groups.yahoo.com/group/thestarneedsacriticmailto:mail@thestarneedsacritic.org?subject=Open%20letter%20to%20the%20Starshapeimage_4_link_0shapeimage_4_link_1
About our former classical music and dance critic, Paul Horsley.
Founded in 1880 by philanthropist William Rockhill Nelson, the Kansas City Star has long been committed to the coverage of the performing arts. On June 16, 2008 it reversed that practice by eliminating the position of Classical Music and Dance Critic. It is our hope that this website and forum will help reverse that decision.
Without a Classical Music and Dance Critic, who will review the performances at Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts?
The completion of Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts is one of the most significant achievements in the history of the Kansas City arts community.  Scheduled to open for the 2010-2011 performance season, the Center will encompass 316,000 square feet and will cover nine acres, including terraced grounds outside. The cost of construction is $358 million.
 
 
"Since 1880, The Kansas City Star has been our area's pre-eminent communications company because of a commitment to one ideal: Building our community through knowledge."
 
"Providing superior service means listening closely to our customers -- readers, subscribers and advertisers -- and dedicating ourselves to their success. We must anticipate their needs and then exceed their expectations."
Do you believe the elimination of our Classical Music and Dance Critic helps "build our community?" Is the Star "exceeding your expectations?" Visit our Forum and join the discussion.
______________________


The performing arts generate $279 million annually in economic impact to Kansas City.
We need a journalistic commitment that reflects our commitment to the performing arts.

The Arts Council of KC's Arts and Culture Economic Activity Study, reported that attendance at cultural arts activities increased form 3.6 million in 1999 to 4.9 million in 2000. Theme park attendance in 2000 was 1.5 million, there were 1.5 million rounds of golf played, and 2.5 million attendance at home games of the Chiefs, Royals, and Wizards in 2000. The study also reported that 41% of the cultural arts attenders came from outside the metro area. link http://groups.yahoo.com/group/thestarneedsacritichttp://www.artskc.org/_FileLibrary/FileImage/ArtsEconPros5pages.pdfshapeimage_6_link_0shapeimage_6_link_1
Paul Horsley was appointed classical music critic of The Kansas City Star in February 2000. Before that he spent eight years as program annotator and musicologist for the Philadelphia Orchestra. He holds degrees in journalism and piano performance from Wichita State University and his Master's and Ph.D. in musicology from Cornell University. He served as music critic in Ithaca, NY, and at the Houston Press, and he was an assistant professor of music history at Louisiana State University. He has received research grants from the Fulbright Foundation and other groups. This summer was a New York Times Fellow at the American Dance Festival's Institute on Dance Criticism in Durham, N.C. He has written on music for Stagebill, The New York Times, Symphony Magazine, Chamber Music, and other publications. He loves Kansas City and just refinanced his Brookside bungalow.
great open letters
 
 
“Music has formed who I am, and it daily alters my perceptions of the world and the people in it. I want nothing more than to have others experience what I have: the tragic thrill of Bach's "St. Matthew Passion," the haunting emptiness and alienation of Berg's "Wozzeck," the sheer acid-rock rush of Mahler's Third. Or for that matter, the stabbing pain of Hank Williams' "I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry." Music's power, after all, is not reserved for the "longhairs" among us.”
 
- Paul Horsley
______________________
 
Excerpts from the Kansas City Star Mission Statement/Motto: link
__________________

“One of the most important civic duties that a newspaper performs is to cover the activities of local arts groups — but it can’t do that effectively without also employing knowledgeable critics who are competent to evaluate the work of those groups. Mere reportage, while essential, is only the first step. It’s not enough to announce that the Hooterville Art Museum finally bought itself a Picasso. You also need a staffer who can tell you whether it’s worth hanging, just as you need someone who knows whether the Hooterville Repertory Company’s production of “Private Lives” was funny for the right reasons.”

- Terry Teachout, Drama Critic, The Wall Street Journal (July 2007)

The Star believes the reporting of our vibrant performing arts scene can be farmed out to freelancers.

How's the Star's coverage so far?
In the time since the Star eliminated the position of Classical Music and Dance Critic, the following articles, written by non-arts staff writers have appeared.

The Star blows the lid off of opera star's weight gain. link

Star reviewer quotes fired Critic's year old review to describe performance he hasn't seen. link

Ballet titan George Balanchine inspires a big "What the...?" from Star writer. link


Derek Donovan, The Star's readers' representative, has a response to your letters. link

Think your arts organization will be unaffected?

In the words of Virgil Thomson, who dominated American music criticism in the ’40s and ’50s: 

"Perhaps criticism is useless. Certainly it is often inefficient. But it is the only antidote we have to paid publicity.’ If you think you can do without that antidote, more power to you — but you’d better be prepared to buy a lot of ads.”

McClatchy owned Miami Herald also releases classical music critic link
(McClatchy is the third-largest newspaper chain in the country and owner of The Star)

Those who attend and support the rich, broad arts scene in Kansas City will have to look to sources other than the Star for credible coverage of this important area of their lives, and another local paper will eventually go under for neglecting what should be its primary mission - covering its own town in a professional manner.

- Ward Holmquist, Artistic Director, Lyric Opera of Kansas City link


The number of full-time classical music critics still working at daily newspapers is now at 27. link
Andrew Adler, Louisville 
Steven Brown, Charlotte Observer 
Scott Cantrell, Dallas Morning News 
Peter Dobrin, Philadelphia Inquirer 
Andrew Druckenbrod, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 
Jeremy Eichler, Boston Globe 
John Fleming, St. Petersburg Times 
Janelle Gelfand, Cincinnati Enquirer 
Mary Kunz Goldman, Buffalo News
Mark Kanny, Pittsburgh Tribune-Review 
Joshua Kosman, SF Chronicle 
Allan Kozinn, New York Times 
Kyle MacMillan, Denver Post 
Anne Midgett, Washington Post 
Sarah Bryan Miller, St. Louis Post-Dispatch 
James Oestreich, NYT 
Don Rosenberg, Cleveland Plain Dealer 
Valerie Scher, San Diego Union-Tribune 
Marc Shulgold, Rocky Mountain News 
Tim Smith, Baltimore Sun 
David Stabler, The Oregonian 
David Patrick Stearns, Philadelphia Inquirer 
Mark Stryker, Detroit Free Press 
Mark Swed, LA Times 
Anthony Tommasini, NYT 
Jon Von Rhein, Chicago Tribune 
Charles Ward, Houston Chronicle http://www.kansascity.com/entertainment/story/670883.htmlhttp://www.kansascity.com/entertainment/story/669523.htmlhttp://www.kansascity.com/238/story/689397.htmlhttp://adastrum.kansascity.com/?q=node/269http://www.artsjournal.com/ontherecord/2008/06/newspapers_and_the_disappearin.htmlhttp://kcopera.wordpress.com/2008/06/26/on-the-demise-of-musical-criticism-paul-horsley-the-star-and-the-kc-arts-scene/http://blog.oregonlive.com/classicalmusic/2008/07/music_critics.htmlshapeimage_7_link_0shapeimage_7_link_1shapeimage_7_link_2shapeimage_7_link_3shapeimage_7_link_4shapeimage_7_link_5shapeimage_7_link_6